Rockbox mail archive

• Next message: Paul van der Heu: "Re: RE : Off Subject: Mailing list modification request"
• Previous message: Michael O'Quinn: "Re: RE : Off Subject: Mailing list modification request"
• In reply to: Linus Nielsen Feltzing: "Re: %ig tag change?"
• Next in thread: Björn Stenberg: "Re: %ig tag change?"
• Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ] [ attachment ]

From: "Linus Nielsen Feltzing" <linus_at_haxx.se>

> Vincent Kargatis wrote:
> > I now see in
> > recent builds that for text-only ID3 genre tags (a known problem
from
> > EAC ripping), instead of null, %ig defaults to 'Blues'.
>
> My immediate thought is: why should Rockbox account for bugs in EAC?

That's why there's already an extant feature request. :) Free text
genre tags aren't that uncommon, in any case.

> However, I feel that we should have a better fallback than just say
"Blues".

The behavior has changed - it used to be (sensibly) if the tag wasn't
recognized, it returned NULL. That was fine with me. But now it seems
to return a single default value - useless, of course.

v

• Next message: Paul van der Heu: "Re: RE : Off Subject: Mailing list modification request"
• Previous message: Michael O'Quinn: "Re: RE : Off Subject: Mailing list modification request"
• In reply to: Linus Nielsen Feltzing: "Re: %ig tag change?"
• Next in thread: Björn Stenberg: "Re: %ig tag change?"
• Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ] [ attachment ]