Rockbox mail archiveSubject: Re: h120: resume vs. play
Re: h120: resume vs. play
From: Christi Alice Scarborough <christi_at_chiark.greenend.org.uk>
Date: Thu, 30 Jun 2005 20:49:12 +0100
Dave Wiard wrote:
> In the file browser, when I hit play with a file selected, I get a
> message saying "Nothing to resume". That's true. I have the player in
> stop mode. Would it be possible to flash up the "Nothing to resume" then
> start playing the selected track? I sometimes hit stop instead of pause
> and it drives me nuts that when I come back "Play" doesn't play.
amicon and I discussed this when I was implementing the new resume
functionality. While I in some sense feel the same as you, we concluded
that this would be confusing, since people would then assume the resume
button was a play button, and be surprised when the Jukebox started to
play a different track to the "one they pressed play on".
It comes down to a choice between behaving in a predictable manner vs
making an intelligent guess as to what the user wants. In the long run,
we feel it's less confusing for the ON button (it's not really a PLAY
button in iRiver Rockbox) to behave in a way that doesn't require you to
remember state in your head as to whether or not a playlist was
playing last time you used it.
Received on 2005-06-30