Rockbox mail archiveSubject: Re: Odd button behaviour (new info)
Re: Odd button behaviour (new info)
From: Ronald Teune <rtwolf_at_gmx.net>
Date: Wed, 07 Dec 2005 20:58:54 +0100
Well, I'll just keep replying to myself, getting closer to the issue...
First, I'll start with earlier misassumptions:
* CBR/VBR has got nothing to do with it
* "on time" has not directly got anything to do with it, but battery state
A few days ago, I flashed back to rombox-20051127. The problems were gone.
Until I turned on the unit yesterday: it almost immediately stopped
playing again - my battery was down to about 10%. I tried ROLO'ing into
ajbrec.ajz: no problems at all.
Then I tried flashing rockbox.ucl, rebooting, and (of course - it still
runs out of ram) no problems.
Flashing rombox, rebooting, it immediately turned off. Then I turned it on
again, and with a quick press on F2 prevented it from turning off again.
Another press on F2 returned me to the WPS. 2 presses on the "on" key got
me to the tree view, then back to the wps again, and after that it showed
"Press OFF to shut down" => the off key was triggered 2 times!
Then flashing rockbox.ucl again: problems were gone.
Somewhere between rombox-2.5 and rombox 20051127 and probably after
October (I forgot what I ran before) there have been changes in rockbox,
causing my unit to behave oddly, triggering the OFF button after another
button, about 90% of the times. But only when ran directly out of flash,
and only at low battery. Perhaps some timing issues?
And now just hope this additional info is meaningful to someone...
a somewhat less puzzled Ronald...
On Sun, 04 Dec 2005 15:30:57 +0100, Ronald Teune <rtwolf_at_gmx.net> wrote:
> It seems that no other user has this problem, or they just don't use the
> daily builds or read the list. I did some additional testing.
> * it seems that the button behaviour is quite right, just after the unit
> is turned on. If the unit's been on for about an hour, maybe two (when
> it's "warmed up"), the problems as described start: after a short or
> long keypress on the left/right/up/down/on button, an "off" event is
> somehow generated. When constantly pressing other buttons (scroll
> through lists, etc), the off event doesn't seem to come through. When
> turning the unit off at that point, and then turning it on again, it
> triggers an off event just after resuming, so music stops again. The
> only "solution" to keep the music playing is to press F2 or F3 after
> resuming the music, because these are the only places that don't exit at
> the off button.
> * at a point like this, I loaded the 2.5 firmware: problems were gone.
> Turning off and on, thus loading the newer firmware again, made the
> problems return. So... was it perhaps because it was flashed? No; I then
> flashed the 2.5 firmware, and still no problem. All the time I made sure
> the same config file was being used, so no different settings (perhaps
> apart from some new features). Now I'm using a flashed 2.5 for some
> time, without problems.
> * I searched through the commits-since-2.5 for "button", but couldn't
> find anything pointing into this direction.
> Am I really the only one with such an odd unit?
Received on 2005-12-07