From: Jonathan Gordon <jdgordy_at_gmail.com>
Date: Sun, 16 Nov 2008 22:48:04 +1100

This suggestion accidentally got brought up in irc and seen as noone
else is around I thought it might be a good idea to discuss.

The idea is to rename settings into groups (i.e "theme.wps" or
"remote.theme.wps").

Pros:
- it would mean settings_list.c would get some much needed love (i.e
organise related settings into groups). settings_list.c has almost no
ordering requirements[1] so this isn't dangerous
- It would mean config files are easier to manage (users could choose
to only save theme. settings or general. or recording. instead of only
having the option of the 3 current flagged groups), it also means
finding settings in the .cfg is easier
- Hopefully would make the setting names consistent
- It could allow for some interesting plugins which wouldn't replace
the menu, but complement them.
- could lead to out-of-menu options

Cons:
- needs a plugin/viewer to convert old .cfg's to new ones.
- a fair amount of work for no "real" benefit
- could lead to out-of-menu options


Another way this could be done is if a dummy grouping option is added
into settings_list for each group (it might get dumping into the .cfg
as [group name] so the current names arent changed).


Thoughts?
Jonathan




[1] - the only order in settings_list.c is the settings which are
loaded into nvram(.bin). So the order only matters if a new one is
added, which is almost never.
Received on 2008-11-16