Rockbox mail archive
Subject: Re: Automatic multi-resume feature for podcasts and audiobooks (FS#11748)
Re: Automatic multi-resume feature for podcasts and audiobooks (FS#11748)
I think my biggest concern about this feature is that it seems
engineered/focused on the use case "having a playlist of multiple files
the user wishes to store independent resume points within" which seems
to me not the most common use case for automatic resuming.
I would expect the general use case for an automatic resume is to resume
a file automatically when selected, but not necessarily for every file
within a playlist.
Is it really that common to have a playlist of separate podcasts and
books all partially complete?
I just feel we should be focusing the offered options and functionality
for the way the majority would use such a feature, and only add things
for the less common cases if it doesn't significantly complicate things.
All these options seem to complicate things. I think a simple auto
resume of "when a file is selected, resume it if possible, but never
otherwise, and store resume points only when a file is stopped" would
cover the vast majority of use cases (though very obviously not the one
that includes multiple incomplete files in a single playlist) without
needing any complex configuration options. An option in the context menu
for "stop without updating resume point" or possibly "return to resume
point" for cases when a file is accidentally opened, or the user
accidentally seeks might benefit as well.
I just feel this feature is very complicated in terms of offered options
for a feature that should be relatively simple and intuitive. It feels
engineered toward what I see as a fringe use case, rather than being a
significant convenience feature for most users. It's the sort of thing
that shouldn't need to be turned on, but rather "just work" while
simultaneously "not get in the way".
Received on 2010-12-15
Page was last modified "Jan 10 2012" The Rockbox Crew